4/10/1923, BB23-BG23, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1923 Benedicts         0  0  0  0  0  4  0  0  1     5 12  1     8  0
1923 Barons            1  4  0  1  5  1  0  0  x    12 16  1     7  0
 
Benedicts            AB  R  H BI   AVG    Barons               AB  R  H BI   AVG
Veach             rf  5  1  2  0  .304    Frisch            2b  4  2  2  1  .250
Cooney            cf  5  0  2  1  .364    Traynor           3b  5  1  2  2  .269
Brower            lf  5  1  0  0  .240    Falk              lf  5  1  3  4  .357
Hornsby           2b  5  1  1  0  .292    Heilmann          1b  4  0  1  0  .417
Grimm             1b  4  1  1  1  .238    Tobin             rf  5  0  0  0  .333
O'Neill,S         c   4  0  2  2  .400     Menosky          cf  0  0  0  0  .000
Lavan             ss  4  0  2  0  .273    O'Farrell         c   4  3  3  0  .400
Prothro           3b  2  0  0  0  .000    Gerber            ss  5  2  3  2  .524
 Ogden            p   0  0  0  0  .000    O'Connell         cf  3  1  1  1  .231
 Wigington        p   0  0  0  0  .000     Blades           rf  0  0  0  0  .625
 Pittenger        ph  1  0  0  0  .333    Pennock           p   2  2  1  1  .200
 Ozmer            p   0  0  0  0  .000                         37 12 16 11
 Fussell          p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Elsh             ph  1  1  1  0  .286
Blankenship,T     p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Gardiner         p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Hendrick         ph  1  0  0  0  .000
 Black            p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Bennett,J        3b  3  0  1  0  .333
                     40  5 12  4
 
Benedicts                        INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Blankenship,T    L 0-1           1.1  7  5  4  0  0  33  21 27.00
Gardiner                         0.2  0  0  0  1  0  14   9  3.86
Black                            2.0  2  1  1  0  0  21  13  7.36
Ogden                            0.2  2  3  3  1  1  21  13 15.43
Wigington                        0.1  3  2  2  0  0  16   9 43.20
Ozmer                            0.1  0  1  1  1  0  10   5  1.93
Fussell                          2.2  2  0  0  0  1  35  23  5.40
                                 8.0 16 12 11  3  2 150  93 
 
Barons                           INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Pennock          W 2-0           9.0 12  5  1  0  3 142  92  1.69
                                 9.0 12  5  1  0  3 142  92 
 
BB : Hendrick batted for Gardiner in the 3rd
     Bennett,J inserted at 3b in the 5th
     Pittenger batted for Wigington in the 6th
     Elsh batted for Fussell in the 9th
BG : Blades inserted at rf in the 9th
     Menosky inserted at cf in the 9th
 
E-Hornsby, Gerber. 2B-O'Neill,S(2), Frisch(2), Falk 2(2), Gerber(1). 
3B-O'Farrell(1), Gerber(1). RBI-Cooney(3), Grimm(1), O'Neill,S 2(7), 
Frisch(2), Traynor 2(5), Falk 4(4), Gerber 2(9), O'Connell(4), Pennock(1). 
CS-Traynor. K-O'Neill,S, Prothro, Bennett,J, Gerber, O'Connell. BB-Heilmann, 
O'Farrell, Pennock. SH-Frisch, Pennock. HBP-O'Connell. PB-O'Farrell. 
HB-Black. 
Temperature: 51, Sky: clear, Wind: right to left at 8 MPH.
4/10/1923, BB23-BG23, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1923 Benedicts         0  0  0  0  0  4  0  0  1     5 12  1     8  0
1923 Barons            1  4  0  1  5  1  0  0  x    12 16  1     7  0
 
 
Benedicts            -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Veach             rf 1>63           53           S            S            note 1    
Cooney            cf   63           53           pb.1-2       S.1-2        S.3-H;1-2 
                                                 7.2-3                               
Brower            lf   9          4>53           e6.3-H;B-1   2/fl         note 2    
Hornsby           2b 2>43           143          S.1-3        31           43        
Grimm             1b   13           43           S.3-H;1-2  8>43                     
O'Neill,S         c    S          5>63           D.2-H;1-H    k                      
Lavan             ss   S.1-2        63           S.2-3        4                      
Prothro           3b   k            43                                               
 Ogden            p                                                                  
 Wigington        p                                                                  
 Pittenger        ph                             9                                   
 Ozmer            p                                                                  
 Fussell          p                                                                  
 Elsh             ph                                        9>S                      
Blankenship,T     p                                                                  
 Gardiner         p                                                                  
 Hendrick         ph 3>8                                                             
 Black            p                                                                  
 Bennett,J        3b              6>13         7>k            S.1-2                  
 
 1: 46/f.2-3;B-1  2: 64/f.2-3;B-1 
 
 
Barons               -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Frisch            2b 1>8            note 1       OA.3xH(21)   Wigington  7>43        
                                               4>D            S.2-H;1-2              
Traynor           3b   63           S.3-H;2-3    31.2-3       S.2-H;1-3    13        
Falk              lf   D            S.3-H;1-2    43.3-H       D.3-H;1-H    53        
Heilmann          1b   e4.2-H;B-2   Gardiner     43           8          8>S         
                                    note 2                                           
                                    W                                                
Tobin             rf   63           6          5>Ogden      6>Ozmer        4/L       
                                                 5            13                     
 Menosky          cf                                                                 
O'Farrell         c  2>S          3>Black        T            W            64/f.B-1  
                                    S                                                
Gerber            ss   D.1-3        64/f.B-1     S.3-H        Fussell      k         
                                                              T.1-H                  
O'Connell         cf   S.3-H;2-3    HBP.1-2      k            8                      
 Blades           rf                                                                 
Pennock           p    S.3-H;1-2    note 3       W.1-2        43                     
 
 1: 34/SH.2-3;1-2  2: CS3(25).1-2  3: 13/SH.2-3;1-2 
 
 
Benedicts        IN OUT ER                  Barons           IN OUT ER                  
Blankenship,T    A1  B3  4 L 0-1            Pennock          A1  E4  1 W 2-0            
Gardiner         B4  B5  0                                                              
Black            B6  C4  1                                                              
Ogden            C5  C9  3                                                              
Wigington        D1  D4  2                                                              
Ozmer            D5  D6  1                                                              
Fussell          D7  E7  0                                                              
4/10/1923, BB23-BG23, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1923 Benedicts         0  0  0  0  0  4  0  0  1     5 12  1     8  0
1923 Barons            1  4  0  1  5  1  0  0  x    12 16  1     7  0
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Benedicts batting
 0-0  0 --- 32  Veach grounded out to short (BCSBBX)
 0-0  1 --- 32  Cooney grounded out to short (BBFCBFFX)
 0-0  2 --- 11  Brower flied out to right (CBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Barons batting
 0-0  0 --- 20  Frisch flied out to center (BBX)
 0-0  1 --- 11  Traynor grounded out to short (BFX)
 0-0  2 --- 01  Falk grounded a double down the third base line (CX)
 0-0  2 -2- 12  Falk scored, Heilmann to second on an error by the second 
                  baseman Hornsby (FSFBX)
 0-1  2 -2- 10  Tobin grounded out to short (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Benedicts batting
 0-1  0 --- 11  Hornsby grounded out to second (CBX)
 0-1  1 --- 12  Grimm grounded out to the mound (CSBX)
 0-1  2 --- 01  O'Neill,S grounded a single between first and second (CX)
 0-1  2 1-- 11  Lavan lined a single to shallow left, O'Neill,S to second 
                  (BC1X)
 0-1  2 12- 22  Prothro struck out (BCBSC)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Barons batting
 0-1  0 --- 21  O'Farrell grounded a single up the middle (BFBX)
 0-1  0 1-- 11  Gerber lined a double to left center, O'Farrell to third 
                  (CB1X)
 0-1  0 -23 00  O'Connell grounded a single up the middle, O'Farrell 
                  scored, Gerber to third (X)
 0-2  0 1-3 01  Pennock lined a single up the middle, Gerber scored, 
                  O'Connell to second (CX)
 0-3  0 12- 00  Frisch sacrifice bunted to first, O'Connell to third, 
                  Pennock to second (Xb)
 0-3  1 -23 10  Traynor lined a single to shallow center, O'Connell 
                  scored, Pennock to third (BX)
 0-4  1 1-3 31  Falk lined a single to shallow center, Pennock scored, 
                  Traynor to second (CBBBX)
                Gardiner now pitching
 0-5  1 12- 01  Traynor was caught stealing third, Falk to second (F>B)
 0-5  2 -2- 32  Heilmann walked (F>B.FFFBBFB)
 0-5  2 12- 12  Tobin popped out to short (BFFFX)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Benedicts batting
                Hendrick pinch hitting for Gardiner
 0-5  0 --- 00  Hendrick flied out to center (X)
 0-5  1 --- 32  Veach grounded out to third (BCBBCX)
 0-5  2 --- 32  Cooney grounded out to third (BBCBCFFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Barons batting
                Black now pitching
 0-5  0 --- 12  O'Farrell grounded a single up the middle (FBCX)
 0-5  0 1-- 10  Gerber grounded to short, forcing O'Farrell at second, 
                  Gerber to first (B1X)
 0-5  1 1-- 11  O'Connell was hit by a pitch, Gerber to second (BFH)
 0-5  1 12- 01  Pennock sacrifice bunted to the mound, Gerber to third, 
                  O'Connell to second (FbXb)
 0-5  2 -23 20  Gerber out at home attempting to advance (BBB)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Benedicts batting
 0-5  0 --- 00  Brower grounded out to third (X)
 0-5  1 --- 32  Hornsby grounded out to the mound (BCBFBX)
 0-5  2 --- 02  Grimm grounded out to second (CFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Barons batting
 0-5  0 --- 11  Frisch lined a double to left center (BFX)
 0-5  0 -2- 00  Traynor grounded out to first, Frisch to third (X)
 0-5  1 --3 01  Falk grounded out to second, Frisch scored (CX)
 0-6  2 --- 00  Heilmann grounded out to second (X)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Benedicts batting
 0-6  0 --- 11  O'Neill,S grounded out to short (FBX)
 0-6  1 --- 20  Lavan grounded out to short (BBX)
 0-6  2 --- 21  Prothro grounded out to second (CBBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Barons batting
                Bennett,J now playing third base
                Ogden now pitching
 0-6  0 --- 00  Tobin popped out to third (X)
 0-6  1 --- 12  O'Farrell tripled deep to right center (CSBX)
 0-6  1 --3 22  Gerber grounded a single up the middle, O'Farrell scored 
                  (FBFFBX)
 0-7  1 1-- 12  O'Connell struck out (FSBFC)
 0-7  2 1-- 31  Pennock walked, Gerber to second (BBCBB)
                Wigington now pitching
 0-7  2 12- 00  Frisch grounded a single between third and short, Gerber 
                  scored, Pennock to second (X)
 0-8  2 12- 21  Traynor lined a single to left center, Pennock scored, 
                  Frisch to third (BCBX)
 0-9  2 1-3 21  Falk doubled deep to right center, Frisch scored, Traynor 
                  scored (BSBX)
 0-11 2 -2- 32  Heilmann flied out to center (FBCBFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Benedicts batting
 0-11 0 --- 01  Bennett,J grounded out to the mound (FX)
 0-11 1 --- 20  Veach lined a single up the middle (BBX)
 0-11 1 1-- 11  O'Farrell allowed a passed ball, Veach to second (BSB)
 0-11 1 -2- 21  Cooney flied out to left, Veach to third (BSB.X)
 0-11 2 --3 11  Veach scored, Brower to first on an error by the 
                  shortstop Gerber (BCX)
 1-11 2 1-- 00  Hornsby grounded a single between first and second, 
                  Brower to third (X)
 1-11 2 1-3 02  Grimm reached on an infield single to short, Brower 
                  scored, Hornsby to second (CCX)
 2-11 2 12- 11  O'Neill,S lined a double to left center, Hornsby scored, 
                  Grimm scored (FBX)
 4-11 2 -2- 10  Lavan lined a single to shallow right, O'Neill,S to third 
                  (BX)
                Pittenger pinch hitting for Wigington
 4-11 2 1-3 02  Pittenger flied out to right (FFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Barons batting
                Ozmer now pitching
 4-11 0 --- 10  Tobin grounded out to the mound (BX)
 4-11 1 --- 32  O'Farrell walked (FBBCFBFB)
                Fussell now pitching
 4-11 1 1-- 10  Gerber lined a triple to left center, O'Farrell scored 
                  (BX)
 4-12 1 --3 12  O'Connell lined out to center (CSBX)
 4-12 2 --3 12  Pennock grounded out to second (FBSX)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Benedicts batting
 4-12 0 --- 12  Bennett,J struck out (CFBS)
 4-12 1 --- 22  Veach lined a single to shallow center (CFBFBX)
 4-12 1 1-- 00  Cooney lined a single to shallow left, Veach to second (X)
 4-12 1 12- 31  Brower popped out to the catcher (BBFBX)
 4-12 2 12- 31  Hornsby grounded out to first (BBBCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Barons batting
 4-12 0 --- 00  Frisch grounded out to second (X)
 4-12 1 --- 32  Traynor grounded out to the mound (CFBBBX)
 4-12 2 --- 10  Falk grounded out to third (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Benedicts batting
 4-12 0 --- 00  Grimm grounded out to second (X)
 4-12 1 --- 12  O'Neill,S struck out (BSFFC)
 4-12 2 --- 31  Lavan popped out to second (BBCBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Barons batting
 4-12 0 --- 20  Heilmann grounded a single between third and short (BBX)
 4-12 0 1-- 02  Tobin lined out to second (CCFX)
 4-12 1 1-- 12  O'Farrell grounded to short, forcing Heilmann at second, 
                  O'Farrell to first (CBFX)
 4-12 2 1-- 22  Gerber struck out (CBFBS)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Benedicts batting
                Blades now playing right field
                Menosky now playing center field
                Elsh pinch hitting for Fussell
 4-12 0 --- 00  Elsh lined a single to shallow center (X)
 4-12 0 1-- 11  Bennett,J grounded a single between third and short, Elsh 
                  to second (CBX)
 4-12 0 12- 01  Veach grounded to second, forcing Bennett,J at second, 
                  Elsh to third, Veach to first (CX)
 4-12 1 1-3 22  Cooney grounded a single between third and short, Elsh 
                  scored, Veach to second (CBBCX)
 5-12 1 12- 11  Brower grounded to short, forcing Cooney at second, Veach 
                  to third, Brower to first (CBX)
 5-12 2 1-3 02  Hornsby grounded out to second (FFX)