4/9/1923, BB23-BG23, Polo Grounds
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E LOB DP
1923 Benedicts 3 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 0 7 10 3 10 1
1923 Barons 3 0 1 2 2 4 2 1 x 15 20 1 11 1
Benedicts AB R H BI AVG Barons AB R H BI AVG
Veach rf 4 1 1 0 .278 Traynor 3b 6 3 4 2 .238
O'Neill,S c 3 2 1 1 .375 Frisch 2b 5 1 1 0 .200
Brower lf 5 2 2 2 .300 Lee lf 4 4 2 3 .400
Hornsby 2b 5 0 1 0 .316 Heilmann 1b 5 2 3 0 .450
Grimm 1b 4 1 1 0 .235 Tobin rf 5 1 2 2 .421
Jones,B 3b 3 0 2 1 .353 Gerber ss 4 0 2 3 .500
Elsh cf 5 0 1 2 .167 O'Farrell c 4 2 2 2 .313
Lavan ss 4 0 0 0 .222 Blades cf 5 2 3 1 .625
Ogden p 0 0 0 0 .000 North p 0 0 0 0 .000
Prothro ph 1 0 0 0 .000 Naylor p 3 0 1 1 .333
Cooney p 2 0 1 0 .353 Menosky cf 1 0 0 0 .000
Black p 0 0 0 0 .000 42 15 20 14
Dorman ph 1 0 0 0 .000
Wigington p 0 0 0 0 .000
Pittenger ss 0 1 0 0 .500
37 7 10 6
Benedicts INN H R ER BB K PCH STR ERA
Cooney L 0-1 3.1 10 6 5 0 2 83 52 13.50
Black 1.2 3 2 2 1 0 26 14 10.80
Wigington 1.1 5 6 6 4 0 46 19 40.50
Ogden 1.2 2 1 1 1 1 26 18 5.40
8.0 20 15 14 6 3 181 103
Barons INN H R ER BB K PCH STR ERA
Naylor W 1-0 7.0 7 5 5 6 3 119 64 6.43
North 2.0 3 2 2 0 1 26 17 9.00
9.0 10 7 7 6 4 145 81
BB : Dorman batted for Black in the 6th
Pittenger inserted at ss in the 7th
Prothro batted for Ogden in the 9th
BG : Menosky inserted at cf in the 8th
E-Veach, Jones,B, Lavan, Heilmann. 2B-Hornsby(2), Jones,B(1), Traynor(1),
Lee(1), Heilmann(3), Tobin(2), O'Farrell(1), Blades(1). 3B-Traynor(1).
HR-Brower(1). RBI-O'Neill,S(5), Brower 2(4), Jones,B(3), Elsh 2(2),
Traynor 2(3), Lee 3(6), Tobin 2(5), Gerber 3(7), O'Farrell 2(2), Blades(3),
Naylor(1). K-Brower, Lavan, Dorman, Prothro, Heilmann, Naylor 2. BB-Veach,
O'Neill,S 2, Grimm, Jones,B 2, Frisch, Lee 2, Tobin, Gerber, O'Farrell.
SH-Heilmann, Naylor. HBP-Pittenger. HB-North.
GWRBI: Gerber
Temperature: 35, Field: wet, Sky: threatening, Wind: out to left at 3 MPH,
Rain Delays: 73 minutes.
4/9/1923, BB23-BG23, Polo Grounds
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E LOB DP
1923 Benedicts 3 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 0 7 10 3 10 1
1923 Barons 3 0 1 2 2 4 2 1 x 15 20 1 11 1
Benedicts -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Veach rf 1>9 8 6 W S.1-2
O'Neill,S c W 3>43 5>W 46/f.B-1 S.2-H;1-3
Brower lf HR.1-H k S.1-2 43 note 1
Hornsby 2b 13 D 3/fl 7>53 6
Grimm 1b S IW 8 63 9>8
Jones,B 3b D.1-H 64/f W.2-3;1-2 W S
Elsh cf 53 4>7 note 2 e3.1-2;B-1 4
Lavan ss 2>9 k 9 64/f
Ogden p
Prothro ph k
Cooney p 7 S
Black p
Dorman ph 6>k
Wigington p
Pittenger ss 8>North
HBP
1: 643/gdp.3-H 2: S.3-H;2-H;1-3
Barons -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Traynor 3b 1>S 43.1-2 4>D note 1 3/g
Frisch 2b S.1-3 43 9.2-3 53 7>9
Lee lf D.3-H;1-H 3>53 e5.3-H;B-1 6>Wigington W
W
Heilmann 1b 3/fl D S.1-2 14/SH.1-2 S.1-3
Tobin rf 43.2-3 43.2-3 Black note 2 W.1-2
D.2-H;1-3
Gerber ss S.3-H S.3-H note 3 8 note 4
O'Farrell c 3/fl S.1-2 5>W D.2-H Ogden
note 5
Blades cf 2>S note 6 S.1-2 D.2-H 63
North p
Naylor p k/b k note 7 S.2-H
Menosky cf 8>163
1: S.3-H;2-H;Bx2(936) 2: S.2-H;B-2(e9/th) 3: 7/dp.3xH(72) 4: W.3-H;2-3;1-2
5: 53.3-H;2-3;1-2 6: e6.2-3;1-2;B-1 7: 14/SH.2-3;1-2
Benedicts -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Veach rf
O'Neill,S c
Brower lf
Hornsby 2b
Grimm 1b
Jones,B 3b
Elsh cf
Lavan ss
Ogden p
Prothro ph
Cooney p
Black p
Dorman ph
Wigington p
Pittenger ss
Barons -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Traynor 3b T
Frisch 2b W
Lee lf S.3-H;1-2
Heilmann 1b k
Tobin rf 13
Gerber ss
O'Farrell c
Blades cf
North p
Naylor p
Menosky cf
Benedicts IN OUT ER Barons IN OUT ER
Cooney A1 C4 5 L 0-1 Naylor A1 D8 5 W 1-0
Black C5 D2 2 North D9 E8 2
Wigington D3 E6 6
Ogden E7 F5 1
4/9/1923, BB23-BG23, Polo Grounds
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E LOB DP
1923 Benedicts 3 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 0 7 10 3 10 1
1923 Barons 3 0 1 2 2 4 2 1 x 15 20 1 11 1
Score O Rnr BS Event
----- - --- -- -----
************** Top of the 1st inning, Benedicts batting
0-0 0 --- 00 Veach flied out to right (X)
Game delayed by rain for 73 minutes
0-0 1 --- 32 O'Neill,S walked (BCBCBB)
0-0 1 1-- 00 Brower homered deep to right, O'Neill,S scored (X)
2-0 1 --- 32 Hornsby grounded out to the mound (FBCBBX)
2-0 2 --- 11 Grimm grounded a single up the middle (BCX)
2-0 2 1-- 10 Jones,B grounded a double down the third base line, Grimm
scored (B1X)
3-0 2 -2- 20 Elsh grounded out to third (BBX)
************** Bottom of the 1st inning, Barons batting
3-0 0 --- 11 Traynor reached on an infield single to first (CBX)
3-0 0 1-- 32 Frisch lined a single down the left field line, Traynor
to third (1FBCBBX)
3-0 0 1-3 00 Lee lined a double to left center, Traynor scored, Frisch
scored (X)
3-2 0 -2- 22 Heilmann popped out to first (FFFBFBX)
3-2 1 -2- 32 Tobin grounded out to second, Lee to third (CBBFBX)
3-2 2 --3 22 Gerber grounded a single between first and second, Lee
scored (CBFBX)
3-3 2 1-- 11 O'Farrell popped out to first (FBX)
************** Top of the 2nd inning, Benedicts batting
3-3 0 --- 00 Lavan flied out to right (X)
3-3 1 --- 00 Cooney lined out to left (X)
3-3 2 --- 31 Veach flied out to center (BBBCX)
************** Bottom of the 2nd inning, Barons batting
3-3 0 --- 02 Blades lined a single to left (FFFX)
3-3 0 1-- 12 Naylor struck out on a fouled bunt (CBbFFb)
3-3 1 1-- 31 Traynor grounded out to second, Blades to second (BFB1BX)
3-3 2 -2- 10 Frisch grounded out to second (BX)
************** Top of the 3rd inning, Benedicts batting
3-3 0 --- 00 O'Neill,S grounded out to second (X)
3-3 1 --- 22 Brower struck out (BCFFBFS)
3-3 2 --- 20 Hornsby doubled deep to left center (BBX)
3-3 2 -2- 30 Grimm was walked intentionally (IIII)
3-3 2 12- 00 Jones,B grounded to short, forcing Grimm at second (X)
************** Bottom of the 3rd inning, Barons batting
3-3 0 --- 10 Lee grounded out to third (BX)
3-3 1 --- 11 Heilmann lined a double to left center (BFX)
3-3 1 -2- 21 Tobin grounded out to second, Heilmann to third (BBCX)
3-3 2 --3 21 Gerber grounded a single between first and second,
Heilmann scored (BCBX)
3-4 2 1-- 21 O'Farrell lined a single to shallow center, Gerber to
second (BBCX)
3-4 2 12- 00 Gerber to third, O'Farrell to second, Blades to first on
an error by the shortstop Lavan (X)
3-4 2 123 12 Naylor struck out (CFBFS)
************** Top of the 4th inning, Benedicts batting
3-4 0 --- 01 Elsh flied out to left (FX)
3-4 1 --- 22 Lavan struck out (FBFBS)
3-4 2 --- 10 Cooney reached on an infield single to third (BX)
3-4 2 1-- 02 Veach popped out to short (FFFX)
************** Bottom of the 4th inning, Barons batting
3-4 0 --- 21 Traynor doubled deep to left (FBBX)
3-4 0 -2- 00 Frisch flied out to right, Traynor to third (X)
3-4 1 --3 12 Traynor scored, Lee to first on an error by the third
baseman Jones,B (CBFX)
3-5 1 1-- 22 Heilmann singled down the left field line and shallow,
Lee to second (BCBF1X)
Black now pitching
3-5 1 12- 10 Tobin doubled deep down the right field line, Lee scored,
Heilmann to third (BX)
3-6 1 -23 32 Gerber flied out into a double play, Brower to O'Neill,S,
Heilmann out at home (BBBCSFX)
************** Top of the 5th inning, Benedicts batting
3-6 0 --- 32 O'Neill,S walked (BBFCBB)
3-6 0 1-- 01 Brower lined a single to shallow right, O'Neill,S to
second (FX)
3-6 0 12- 32 Hornsby popped out to first (BCSFBFBX)
3-6 1 12- 32 Grimm flied out to center (BCBCBX)
3-6 2 12- 31 Jones,B walked, O'Neill,S to third, Brower to second
(CBBBB)
3-6 2 123 21 Elsh grounded a single up the middle, O'Neill,S scored,
Brower scored, Jones,B to third (BFBX)
5-6 2 1-3 10 Lavan flied out to right (1BX)
************** Bottom of the 5th inning, Barons batting
5-6 0 --- 32 O'Farrell walked (BBCFBB)
5-6 0 1-- 11 Blades grounded a single up the middle, O'Farrell to
second (SBX)
5-6 0 12- 00 Naylor sacrifice bunted to the mound, O'Farrell to third,
Blades to second (Xb)
5-6 1 -23 11 Traynor lined a single to right, O'Farrell scored, Blades
scored, Traynor out at second (FBX)
5-8 2 --- 21 Frisch grounded out to third (BFBX)
************** Top of the 6th inning, Benedicts batting
Dorman pinch hitting for Black
5-8 0 --- 02 Dorman struck out (CFC)
5-8 1 --- 30 Veach walked (BBBB)
5-8 1 1-- 12 O'Neill,S grounded to second, forcing Veach at second,
O'Neill,S to first (BCFX)
5-8 2 1-- 00 Brower grounded out to second (X)
************** Bottom of the 6th inning, Barons batting
Wigington now pitching
5-8 0 --- 30 Lee walked (BBBB)
5-8 0 1-- 00 Heilmann sacrifice bunted to the mound, Lee to second (Xb)
5-8 1 -2- 32 Tobin lined a single to right, Lee scored, Tobin to
second on an error by the right fielder Veach (BFBBFX)
5-9 1 -2- 22 Gerber flied out to center (BBFFX)
5-9 2 -2- 00 O'Farrell doubled deep to center, Tobin scored (X)
5-10 2 -2- 32 Blades doubled deep to left center, O'Farrell scored
(FBBBCX)
5-11 2 -2- 21 Naylor lined a single down the right field line, Blades
scored (BFBX)
5-12 2 1-- 10 Traynor grounded out to first (BX)
************** Top of the 7th inning, Benedicts batting
5-12 0 --- 10 Hornsby grounded out to third (BX)
5-12 1 --- 01 Grimm grounded out to short (CX)
5-12 2 --- 31 Jones,B walked (BBBCB)
5-12 2 1-- 22 Jones,B to second, Elsh to first on an error by the first
baseman Heilmann (CBFBX)
5-12 2 12- 10 Lavan grounded to short, forcing Elsh at second (BX)
************** Bottom of the 7th inning, Barons batting
5-12 0 --- 01 Frisch lined out to right (FX)
5-12 1 --- 31 Lee walked (BBBCB)
5-12 1 1-- 00 Heilmann grounded a single up the middle, Lee to third (X)
5-12 1 1-3 30 Tobin walked, Heilmann to second (BBBB)
5-12 1 123 31 Gerber walked, Lee scored, Heilmann to third, Tobin to
second (BCBBB)
Pittenger now playing shortstop
Ogden now pitching
5-13 1 123 32 O'Farrell grounded out to third, Heilmann scored, Tobin
to third, Gerber to second (BCBSBX)
5-14 2 -23 01 Blades grounded out to short (CX)
************** Top of the 8th inning, Benedicts batting
Menosky now playing center field
North now pitching
5-14 0 --- 22 Pittenger was hit by a pitch (CBFFBH)
5-14 0 1-- 10 Veach lined a single to shallow left, Pittenger to second
(BX)
5-14 0 12- 00 O'Neill,S lined a single down the right field line,
Pittenger scored, Veach to third (X)
6-14 0 1-3 10 Brower grounded into a double play, Gerber to Frisch to
Heilmann, Veach scored (BX)
7-14 2 --- 12 Hornsby popped out to short (SBFX)
************** Bottom of the 8th inning, Barons batting
7-14 0 --- 01 Menosky grounded out to the mound (SX)
7-14 1 --- 00 Traynor tripled deep to left center (X)
7-14 1 --3 31 Frisch walked (BCBBB)
7-14 1 1-3 00 Lee lined a single to shallow left, Traynor scored,
Frisch to second (X)
7-15 1 12- 12 Heilmann struck out (CCBS)
7-15 2 12- 02 Tobin grounded out to the mound (CFFFX)
************** Top of the 9th inning, Benedicts batting
7-15 0 --- 20 Grimm lined out to center (BBX)
7-15 1 --- 12 Jones,B lined a single to shallow center (CBFX)
7-15 1 1-- 00 Elsh popped out to second (X)
Prothro pinch hitting for Ogden
7-15 2 1-- 02 Prothro struck out (FFS)