9/23/1919, Sta19-Ga19, Polo Grounds (A)
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Bulldogs          1  2  5  0  0  0  0  0  0  0     8  9  1    11  3
1919 Pines             0  0  1  0  4  0  2  0  1  1     9 17  3    12  1
 
Bulldogs             AB  R  H BI   AVG    Pines                AB  R  H BI   AVG
Collins,E         2b  5  1  3  3  .319    Smith,R           lf  6  2  3  0  .259
Wood              rf  3  0  0  0  .234    Hooper            rf  6  0  3  1  .262
Judge             1b  5  1  0  1  .297    Fletcher          ss  6  1  2  2  .319
Peckinpaugh       ss  5  0  0  0  .308    Gainer            1b  4  3  2  1  .222
Southworth        lf  2  1  1  0  .310    Stock             3b  3  0  0  0  .344
Bodie             cf  4  2  1  0  .283    Strunk            cf  3  1  2  2  .293
Lavan             3b  5  1  1  1  .260    Janvrin           2b  1  0  0  0  .164
Ainsmith          c   5  2  3  3  .321     Herzog           ph  3  0  3  1  .282
 Thomas,P         c   0  0  0  0  .167    Schmidt           c   5  0  2  2  .300
Harper            p   1  0  0  0  .178    Naylor            p   0  0  0  0  .266
 Lowdermilk       p   1  0  0  0  .167     Watson,Mi        p   2  1  0  0  .051
 Leifield         p   1  0  0  0  .313     Barry            ph  1  0  0  0  .204
 Shellenback      p   0  0  0  0  .000     Wilkinson        p   1  0  0  0  .150
                     37  8  9  8           Ayers            p   0  0  0  0  .192
                                           Williams,K       ph  0  1  0  0  .317
                                                               41  9 17  9
 
Bulldogs                         INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Harper                           4.2  9  5  5  4  0  99  55  3.67
Lowdermilk                       2.1  4  2  2  1  0  38  22  2.38
Leifield         BS 9, L 8-4     2.0  1  2  2  2  2  32  16  3.94
Shellenback                      0.0  3  0  0  0  0  10   5  3.58
                                 9.0 17  9  9  7  2 179  98 
 
Pines                            INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Naylor                           2.1  4  7  6  4  0  59  23  4.06
Watson,Mi                        3.2  4  1  1  2  0  65  37  5.24
Wilkinson                        2.0  0  0  0  2  2  32  17  4.41
Ayers            W 12-9          2.0  1  0  0  0  0  18  12  4.05
                                10.0  9  8  7  8  2 174  89 
 
Sta: Thomas,P inserted at c in the 9th
Ga : Herzog batted for Janvrin in the 5th
     Herzog moved to 2b in the 6th
     Barry batted for Watson,Mi in the 6th
     Williams,K batted for Ayers in the 10th
 
E-Lavan, Fletcher, Janvrin, Schmidt. 2B-Collins,E(27). 3B-Ainsmith(20), 
Smith,R(2). RBI-Collins,E 3(65), Judge(123), Lavan(60), Ainsmith 3(63), 
Hooper(32), Fletcher 2(93), Gainer(76), Strunk 2(30), Schmidt 2(28), 
Herzog(68). SB-Collins,E 2(57), Judge(24), Southworth(46), Gainer(20). 
CS-Hooper. K-Peckinpaugh, Lowdermilk, Smith,R, Stock. BB-Collins,E, Wood, 
Southworth 3, Bodie, Harper 2, Gainer, Stock 2, Strunk 2, Janvrin, 
Williams,K. SH-Wood, Peckinpaugh. SF-Judge. HBP-Wood. HB-Watson,Mi. 
GWRBI: Fletcher
Temperature: 69, Sky: clear, Wind: in from left at 9 MPH.
9/23/1919, Sta19-Ga19, Polo Grounds (A)
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Bulldogs          1  2  5  0  0  0  0  0  0  0     8  9  1    11  3
1919 Pines             0  0  1  0  4  0  2  0  1  1     9 17  3    12  1
 
 
Bulldogs             -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Collins,E         2b 1>S            note 1       note 2       S            W         
Wood              rf   SB2          13           e4.1-2;B-1   note 3       W.1-2     
                       54/SH.2-3                              HBP                    
Judge             1b   8/SF.3-H   3>e6.B-1       31           13           43        
Peckinpaugh       ss   5/L          14/SH.1-2  4>63         6>4          8>k         
Southworth        lf 2>W            SB3          S            W            7         
                                    W                                                
Bodie             cf   46/f.B-1     W.1-2        9            SB2          63        
                                                              S.2-3                  
Lavan             3b   9            note 4       9            463/gdp    9>Ayers     
                                                                           53        
Ainsmith          c    S.1-3        Watson,Mi  5>63         7>Wilkinson    S         
                                    note 5                    63                     
 Thomas,P         c                                                                  
Harper            p    W.1-2        W            8                                   
 Lowdermilk       p                                           k                      
 Leifield         p                                                        36/b/f.B-1
 Shellenback      p                                                                  
 
 1: D.3-H;2-H;1-3  2: 46/f.3-H;1x2;B-1  3: SB2.1-3(e2/th)  4: S.3-H;2-3;1-2 
 5: T.3-H;2-H;1-H 
 
 
Pines                -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Smith,R           lf 1>63           T            S.1-2        6          8>Leifield  
                                                                           k         
Hooper            rf   S            S.3-H        8            3/g          53        
Fletcher          ss   9            463/gdp      S.2-H;1-3  7>43           43        
Gainer            1b   CS2(24)    4>53           S.3-H;1-3    S          9>W         
                     2>e5.B-1                                                        
Stock             3b   43.1-2       W            W.1-2        43.1-2       SB2       
                                                                           k         
Strunk            cf   W            S.1-2        note 1       W            3/g.2-3   
Janvrin           2b   W.2-3;1-2    463/gdp      Lowdermilk                          
 Herzog           ph                             S.2-3;1-2    S.2-3;1-2    S.3-H     
Schmidt           c    523/gdp    5>S            64/f         note 2       4         
Naylor            p                                                                  
 Watson,Mi        p  3>8            14/f.B-1                                         
 Barry            ph                           6>7                                   
 Wilkinson        p                                           63                     
 Ayers            p                                                                  
 Williams,K       ph                                                     0>W         
 
 1: S.3-H;2-H;1-2  2: S.3-H;2-H;1-2 
 
 
Bulldogs             -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Collins,E         2b   54/f                                                          
Wood              rf 0>8                                                             
                                                                                     
Judge             1b   43                                                            
Peckinpaugh       ss   13                                                            
Southworth        lf                                                                 
                                                                                     
Bodie             cf                                                                 
                                                                                     
Lavan             3b                                                                 
                                                                                     
Ainsmith          c                                                                  
                                                                                     
 Thomas,P         c                                                                  
Harper            p                                                                  
 Lowdermilk       p                                                                  
 Leifield         p                                                                  
 Shellenback      p                                                                  
 
 
Pines                -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Smith,R           lf   note 1                                                        
                       S/b.1-2                                                       
Hooper            rf   S.2-3;1-2                                                     
Fletcher          ss   note 2                                                        
Gainer            1b                                                                 
                                                                                     
Stock             3b                                                                 
                                                                                     
Strunk            cf                                                                 
Janvrin           2b                                                                 
 Herzog           ph                                                                 
Schmidt           c                                                                  
Naylor            p                                                                  
 Watson,Mi        p                                                                  
 Barry            ph                                                                 
 Wilkinson        p                                                                  
 Ayers            p                                                                  
 Williams,K       ph                                                                 
 
 1: Shellenback  2: S.3-H;2-3;1-2 
 
 
Bulldogs         IN OUT ER                  Pines            IN OUT ER                  
Harper           A1  C6  5                  Naylor           A1  B7  6                  
Lowdermilk       C7  D9  2                  Watson,Mi        B8  D7  1                  
Leifield         E1  E9  2 BS 9, L 8-4      Wilkinson        D8  E6  0                  
Shellenback      F1  F3  0                  Ayers            E7  F4  0 W 12-9           
9/23/1919, Sta19-Ga19, Polo Grounds (A)
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Bulldogs          1  2  5  0  0  0  0  0  0  0     8  9  1    11  3
1919 Pines             0  0  1  0  4  0  2  0  1  1     9 17  3    12  1
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Bulldogs batting
 0-0  0 --- 20  Collins,E grounded a single between third and short (BBX)
 0-0  0 1-- 00  Collins,E stole second (1>B)
 0-0  0 -2- 10  Wood sacrifice bunted to third, Collins,E to third 
                  (1>B.Xb)
 0-0  1 --3 31  Judge hit a sacrifice fly to center, Collins,E scored 
                  (BBBCX)
 1-0  2 --- 20  Peckinpaugh lined out to third (BBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Pines batting
 1-0  0 --- 11  Smith,R grounded out to short (BFX)
 1-0  1 --- 31  Hooper reached on an infield single to second (FBBBX)
 1-0  1 1-- 21  Fletcher flied out to right (SBB1X)
 1-0  2 1-- 10  Hooper was caught stealing second (B1>C)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Bulldogs batting
 1-0  0 --- 30  Southworth walked (BBBB)
 1-0  0 1-- 00  Bodie grounded to second, forcing Southworth at second, 
                  Bodie to first (X)
 1-0  1 1-- 22  Lavan flied out to right (1FB1BCX)
 1-0  2 1-- 10  Ainsmith singled to right center, Bodie to third (B1X)
 1-0  2 1-3 31  Harper walked, Ainsmith to second (BBBC1B)
 1-0  2 123 10  Collins,E lined a double to right center, Bodie scored, 
                  Ainsmith scored, Harper to third (BX)
 3-0  2 -23 32  Wood grounded out to the mound (FBBCFFBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Pines batting
 3-0  0 --- 21  Gainer to first on an error by the third baseman Lavan 
                  (BCBX)
 3-0  0 1-- 01  Stock grounded out to second, Gainer to second (SX)
 3-0  1 -2- 32  Strunk walked (BCSBBFB)
 3-0  1 12- 30  Janvrin walked, Gainer to third, Strunk to second (BBBB)
 3-0  1 123 22  Schmidt grounded into a double play, Lavan to Ainsmith to 
                  Judge (CFBFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Bulldogs batting
 3-0  0 --- 10  Judge to first on an error by the shortstop Fletcher (BX)
 3-0  0 1-- 20  Peckinpaugh sacrifice bunted to the mound, Judge to 
                  second (1BBXb)
 3-0  1 -2- 10  Judge stole third (B>C)
 3-0  1 --3 31  Southworth walked (B>C.BBB)
 3-0  1 1-3 30  Bodie walked, Southworth to second (BBBB)
 3-0  1 123 22  Lavan singled to shallow right, Judge scored, Southworth 
                  to third, Bodie to second (BFFBX)
                Watson,Mi now pitching
 4-0  1 123 31  Ainsmith tripled deep to right center, Southworth scored, 
                  Bodie scored, Lavan scored (CBBBX)
 7-0  1 --3 32  Harper walked (CBBBFFB)
 7-0  1 1-3 31  Collins,E grounded to second, forcing Harper at second, 
                  Ainsmith scored, Harper out at second, Collins,E to 
                  first (BBBCX)
 8-0  2 1-- 12  Collins,E to second, Wood to first on an error by the 
                  second baseman Janvrin (FFBX)
 8-0  2 12- 00  Judge grounded out to first (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Pines batting
 8-0  0 --- 11  Watson,Mi flied out to center (BFX)
 8-0  1 --- 11  Smith,R tripled deep to right center (BFX)
 8-0  1 --3 10  Hooper grounded a single up the middle, Smith,R scored 
                  (BX)
 8-1  1 1-- 01  Fletcher grounded into a double play, Collins,E to 
                  Peckinpaugh to Judge (FX)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Bulldogs batting
 8-1  0 --- 01  Peckinpaugh grounded out to short (SX)
 8-1  1 --- 11  Southworth lined a single to right center (CBX)
 8-1  1 1-- 10  Bodie flied out to right (BX)
 8-1  2 1-- 11  Lavan lined out to right (CBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Pines batting
 8-1  0 --- 32  Gainer grounded out to third (BCSBFFFFFBFX)
 8-1  1 --- 30  Stock walked (BBBB)
 8-1  1 1-- 00  Strunk grounded a single between first and second, Stock 
                  to second (X)
 8-1  1 12- 32  Janvrin grounded into a double play, Collins,E to 
                  Peckinpaugh to Judge (CCFBFBFFFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Bulldogs batting
 8-1  0 --- 11  Ainsmith grounded out to short (CBX)
 8-1  1 --- 22  Harper popped out to center (CFBBX)
 8-1  2 --- 01  Collins,E lined a single to shallow left (CX)
 8-1  2 1-- 01  Collins,E stole second, Collins,E to third on an error by 
                  the catcher Schmidt (C>C)
 8-1  2 --3 12  Wood was hit by a pitch (C>C.FBH)
 8-1  2 1-3 00  Judge grounded out to the mound (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Pines batting
 8-1  0 --- 00  Schmidt lined a single to right center (X)
 8-1  0 1-- 02  Watson,Mi grounded to the mound, forcing Schmidt at 
                  second, Watson,Mi to first (CCbX)
 8-1  1 1-- 10  Smith,R lined a single to shallow left, Watson,Mi to 
                  second (BX)
 8-1  1 12- 20  Hooper flied out to center (BBX)
 8-1  2 12- 32  Fletcher grounded a single up the middle, Watson,Mi 
                  scored, Smith,R to third (FBBBC>X)
 8-2  2 1-3 20  Gainer singled to right center, Smith,R scored, Fletcher 
                  to third (BBX)
 8-3  2 1-3 31  Stock walked, Gainer to second (BBBCB)
 8-3  2 123 00  Strunk grounded a single up the middle, Fletcher scored, 
                  Gainer scored, Stock to second (X)
                Lowdermilk now pitching
                Herzog pinch hitting for Janvrin
 8-5  2 12- 00  Herzog reached on an infield single to first, Stock to 
                  third, Strunk to second (X)
 8-5  2 123 31  Schmidt grounded to short, forcing Herzog at second 
                  (CBBBX)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Bulldogs batting
                Herzog moved to second base
 8-5  0 --- 21  Peckinpaugh popped out to second (CBBX)
 8-5  1 --- 32  Southworth walked (BBCBFB)
 8-5  1 1-- 00  Southworth stole second (>B)
 8-5  1 -2- 32  Bodie reached on an infield single to short, Southworth 
                  to third (>B.BCCBX)
 8-5  1 1-3 00  Lavan grounded into a double play, Herzog to Fletcher to 
                  Gainer (1X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Pines batting
                Barry pinch hitting for Watson,Mi
 8-5  0 --- 10  Barry lined out to left (BX)
 8-5  1 --- 12  Smith,R popped out to short (CFBX)
 8-5  2 --- 32  Hooper grounded out to first (CFFBBBX)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Bulldogs batting
                Wilkinson now pitching
 8-5  0 --- 00  Ainsmith grounded out to short (X)
 8-5  1 --- 12  Lowdermilk struck out (CFBS)
 8-5  2 --- 32  Collins,E walked (SBBBFFB)
 8-5  2 1-- 32  Wood walked, Collins,E to second (FBB1BC>F>B)
 8-5  2 12- 21  Judge grounded out to second (BBCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Pines batting
 8-5  0 --- 10  Fletcher grounded out to second (BX)
 8-5  1 --- 11  Gainer lined a single to right center (CBX)
 8-5  1 1-- 00  Stock grounded out to second, Gainer to second (X)
 8-5  2 -2- 30  Strunk walked (BBBB)
 8-5  2 12- 02  Herzog reached on an infield single to second, Gainer to 
                  third, Strunk to second (FCFX)
 8-5  2 123 00  Schmidt lined a single to shallow left, Gainer scored, 
                  Strunk scored, Herzog to second (X)
 8-7  2 12- 21  Wilkinson grounded out to short (CBBX)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Bulldogs batting
 8-7  0 --- 22  Peckinpaugh struck out (FBBSS)
 8-7  1 --- 00  Southworth flied out to left (X)
 8-7  2 --- 20  Bodie grounded out to short (BBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Pines batting
                Leifield now pitching
 8-7  0 --- 02  Smith,R struck out (FSC)
 8-7  1 --- 21  Hooper grounded out to third (BBCX)
 8-7  2 --- 22  Fletcher grounded out to second (CBFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Bulldogs batting
                Ayers now pitching
 8-7  0 --- 12  Lavan grounded out to third (BCCFX)
 8-7  1 --- 11  Ainsmith lined a single to right center (CBX)
 8-7  1 1-- 00  Leifield bunted into an out to first, forcing Ainsmith at 
                  second, Leifield to first (Xb)
 8-7  2 1-- 00  Collins,E grounded to third, forcing Leifield at second 
                  (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 9th inning, Pines batting
                Thomas,P now playing catcher
 8-7  0 --- 31  Gainer walked (BBBCB)
 8-7  0 1-- 01  Gainer stole second (1F>B)
 8-7  0 -2- 22  Stock struck out (1F>B.BFS)
 8-7  1 -2- 20  Strunk grounded out to first, Gainer to third (BBX)
 8-7  2 --3 01  Herzog lined a single to left center, Gainer scored (CX)
 8-8  2 1-- 00  Schmidt popped out to second (X)
 
**************  Top of the 10th inning, Bulldogs batting
 8-8  0 --- 20  Wood flied out to center (BBX)
 8-8  1 --- 21  Judge grounded out to second (FBBX)
 8-8  2 --- 00  Peckinpaugh grounded out to the mound (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 10th inning, Pines batting
                Williams,K pinch hitting for Ayers
 8-8  0 --- 30  Williams,K walked (BBBB)
                Shellenback now pitching
 8-8  0 1-- 10  Smith,R bunted for a single, Williams,K to second (BbXb)
 8-8  0 12- 32  Hooper lined a single to shallow right, Williams,K to 
                  third, Smith,R to second (BBbCbBFX)
 8-8  0 123 10  Fletcher singled to center, Williams,K scored, Smith,R to 
                  third, Hooper to second (BX)