4/13/1919, Ga19-Geo19, Comiskey Park 
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Pines             0  0  0  0  0  1  4  0  0  0  0  0     5  9  3     9  2
1919 Giants            1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0  0  1     6 14  0    14  0
 
Pines                AB  R  H BI   AVG    Giants               AB  R  H BI   AVG
Smith,R           lf  6  1  1  0  .161    Johnston,J        2b  6  3  3  0  .379
Hooper            rf  3  0  1  0  .360    Stengel           lf  5  1  1  0  .296
 Janvrin          ph  1  1  1  2  .250    Youngs            rf  6  0  3  2  .481
 Ayers            p   0  0  0  0  .000    Boeckel           3b  3  1  1  2  .333
 Watson,Mi        p   2  0  0  0  .250    Snyder,F          c   3  0  0  0  .300
 Thompson         p   0  0  0  0  .143     Smith,Ea         ph  1  0  0  0  .000
Herzog            2b  6  0  2  2  .227     Tragesser        c   1  0  1  1  .364
Gainer            1b  5  0  1  1  .148     Kerr             pr  0  0  0  0  .200
Stock             3b  5  0  0  0  .233     Smith,ES         c   1  1  1  0 1.000
Picinich          c   5  1  1  0  .286    Williams,C        cf  3  0  2  0  .214
Fletcher          ss  4  1  2  0  .267    Terry             ss  2  0  0  0  .250
Strunk            cf  2  0  0  0  .188     Horstmann        p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Barry            ph  1  0  0  0  .000     Jamieson         ph  1  0  0  0  .000
 Williams,K       cf  2  0  0  0  .286     Snyder,B         p   1  0  0  0  .000
Smith,S           p   2  1  0  0  .000     Ragan            ph  1  0  1  0 1.000
 Sloan            rf  1  0  0  0  .250    Holke             1b  5  0  1  1  .114
                     45  5  9  5          Schupp            p   2  0  0  0  .000
                                           Smith,Ji         ss  3  0  0  0  .200
                                                               44  6 14  6
 
Pines                            INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Smith,S                          6.0  7  3  1  2  3  81  55  9.00
Ayers            H 1             1.1  2  1  0  2  0  39  22  5.06
Watson,Mi        BS 1, L 0-1     3.2  3  2  2  2  1  48  29  3.86
Thompson                         0.0  2  0  0  1  0   9   4 13.50
                                11.0 14  6  3  7  4 177 110 
 
Giants                           INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Schupp                           6.2  8  5  5  3  3 126  70  4.82
Horstmann                        1.1  0  0  0  2  1  20   9  0.00
Snyder,B         W 1-0           4.0  1  0  0  0  2  49  29  0.00
                                12.0  9  5  5  5  6 195 108 
 
Ga : Barry batted for Strunk in the 7th
     Janvrin batted for Hooper in the 7th
     Williams,K inserted at cf in the 7th
     Sloan inserted at rf in the 7th
Geo: Smith,Ji inserted at ss in the 7th
     Smith,Ea batted for Snyder,F in the 7th
     Tragesser inserted at c in the 8th
     Jamieson batted for Horstmann in the 8th
     Kerr ran for Tragesser in the 9th
     Smith,ES inserted at c in the 10th
     Ragan batted for Snyder,B in the 12th
 
E-Smith,R, Herzog, Ayers. 2B-Smith,R(1), Johnston,J(2), Youngs(5), 
Boeckel(2), Williams,C(1), Smith,ES(1). RBI-Herzog 2(2), Gainer(1), 
Janvrin 2(2), Youngs 2(9), Boeckel 2(6), Holke(3), Tragesser(3). 
SB-Herzog(1), Boeckel(1), Williams,C(1). K-Gainer 2, Fletcher 2, Williams,K, 
Sloan, Stengel, Williams,C, Schupp, Smith,Ji. BB-Gainer, Stock, Fletcher, 
Smith,S, Sloan, Stengel, Boeckel 2, Williams,C 3, Holke. SH-Terry. 
SF-Boeckel. PB-Tragesser. 
GWRBI: Holke
Temperature: 63, Sky: clear, Wind: in from right at 16 MPH.
4/13/1919, Ga19-Geo19, Comiskey Park 
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Pines             0  0  0  0  0  1  4  0  0  0  0  0     5  9  3     9  2
1919 Giants            1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0  0  1     6 14  0    14  0
 
 
Pines                -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Smith,R           lf 1>13           53         6>D            8            7         
Hooper            rf   63           S            43.2-3                              
 Janvrin          ph                                          note 1                 
 Ayers            p                                                                  
 Watson,Mi        p                                                      9>Snyder,B  
                                                                           9         
 Thompson         p                                                                  
Herzog            2b   S            54/f         43.3-H       S.3-H;1-3    43        
Gainer            1b   SB2        4>k            W            S.3-H;1-2    k         
                       3/g                                                           
Stock             3b 2>W            43           43           Horstmann  0>3/g       
                                                              43                     
Picinich          c    43.1-2       53         7>S          8>63           53        
Fletcher          ss   k          5>k            S.1-2        W            S         
Strunk            cf   63           13                                               
 Barry            ph                             63.2-3;1-2                          
 Williams,K       cf                                          pb.1-2       8         
                                                              k                      
Smith,S           p  3>7            43           W                                   
 Sloan            rf                                          W          1>k         
 
 1: S.3-H;2-H;1-3 
 
 
Giants               -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Johnston,J        2b 1>9            D            S            S            3         
Stengel           lf   S.B-2(e7)    k            e4.1-2;B-1   W.1-2      9>4         
Youngs            rf   9            D.2-H        S.2-H;1-2    note 1       13        
Boeckel           3b   D.2-H        63           W.2-3;1-2    7/SF.3-H     W         
Snyder,F          c    53         4>63           523/gdp                             
 Smith,Ea         ph                                          64/f                   
 Tragesser        c                                                        SB2       
                                                                           S.2-H     
 Kerr             pr                                                                 
 Smith,ES         c                                                                  
Williams,C        cf 2>S            W          6>k          8>D            W.1-2     
                                                                                     
Terry             ss   13/SH.1-2    SB2          3/fl                                
                                    8                                                
 Horstmann        p                                                                  
 Jamieson         ph                                          7                      
 Snyder,B         p                                                        8         
 Ragan            ph                                                                 
Holke             1b   9            63           43           IW         0>7         
Schupp            p    PO2(14)    5>k                                                
                     3>63                                                            
 Smith,Ji         ss                           7>Ayers        Watson,Mi    k         
                                                 53           7.2-3                  
 
 1: e1.2-3;1-2;B-1 
 
 
Pines                -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Smith,R           lf   3/g                                                           
Hooper            rf                                                                 
 Janvrin          ph                                                                 
 Ayers            p                                                                  
 Watson,Mi        p    63                                                            
                                                                                     
 Thompson         p                                                                  
Herzog            2b 2>23                                                            
Gainer            1b   9                                                             
                                                                                     
Stock             3b   63                                                            
                                                                                     
Picinich          c                                                                  
Fletcher          ss                                                                 
Strunk            cf                                                                 
 Barry            ph                                                                 
 Williams,K       cf                                                                 
                                                                                     
Smith,S           p                                                                  
 Sloan            rf                                                                 
 
 
Giants               -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Johnston,J        2b   8                                                             
Stengel           lf 1>43                                                            
Youngs            rf   S                                                             
Boeckel           3b   463/gdp                                                       
Snyder,F          c                                                                  
 Smith,Ea         ph                                                                 
 Tragesser        c                                                                  
                                                                                     
 Kerr             pr                                                                 
 Smith,ES         c  2>D                                                             
Williams,C        cf   Thompson                                                      
                       IW                                                            
Terry             ss                                                                 
                                                                                     
 Horstmann        p                                                                  
 Jamieson         ph                                                                 
 Snyder,B         p                                                                  
 Ragan            ph   S.2-3;1-2                                                     
Holke             1b   note 1                                                        
Schupp            p                                                                  
                                                                                     
 Smith,Ji         ss                                                                 
                                                                                     
 
 1: S.3-H;2-3;1-2 
 
 
Pines            IN OUT ER                  Giants           IN OUT ER                  
Smith,S          A1  C8  1                  Schupp           A1  D4  5                  
Ayers            C9  D8  0 H 1              Horstmann        D5  E1  0                  
Watson,Mi        D9  F5  2 BS 1, L 0-1      Snyder,B         E2  F5  0 W 1-0            
Thompson         F6  F8  0                                                              
4/13/1919, Ga19-Geo19, Comiskey Park 
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Pines             0  0  0  0  0  1  4  0  0  0  0  0     5  9  3     9  2
1919 Giants            1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0  0  1     6 14  0    14  0
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Pines batting
 0-0  0 --- 22  Smith,R grounded out to the mound (BBCFX)
 0-0  1 --- 31  Hooper grounded out to short (BBBCX)
 0-0  2 --- 10  Herzog grounded a single up the middle (BX)
 0-0  2 1-- 21  Herzog stole second (CBB>C)
 0-0  2 -2- 32  Gainer grounded out to first (CBB>C.BFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Giants batting
 0-0  0 --- 00  Johnston,J flied out to right (X)
 0-0  1 --- 21  Stengel lined a single to shallow left, Stengel to second 
                  on an error by the left fielder Smith,R (BCBX)
 0-0  1 -2- 11  Youngs flied out to right (CBX)
 0-0  2 -2- 00  Boeckel doubled deep to left center, Stengel scored (X)
 0-1  2 -2- 00  Snyder,F grounded out to third (X)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Pines batting
 0-1  0 --- 31  Stock walked (BBBCB)
 0-1  0 1-- 02  Picinich grounded out to second, Stock to second (CFX)
 0-1  1 -2- 02  Fletcher struck out (SFC)
 0-1  2 -2- 22  Strunk grounded out to short (BSBCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Giants batting
 0-1  0 --- 02  Williams,C lined a single to right center (CSFX)
 0-1  0 1-- 01  Terry sacrifice bunted to the mound, Williams,C to second 
                  (FXb)
 0-1  1 -2- 02  Holke lined out to right (CFX)
 0-1  2 -2- 00  Williams,C was picked off second by Smith,S (2)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Pines batting
 0-1  0 --- 10  Smith,S flied out to left (BX)
 0-1  1 --- 20  Smith,R grounded out to third (BBX)
 0-1  2 --- 21  Hooper lined a single to shallow right (CBBX)
 0-1  2 1-- 22  Herzog grounded to third, forcing Hooper at second 
                  (C1B11FB11X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Giants batting
 0-1  0 --- 02  Schupp grounded out to short (CCX)
 0-1  1 --- 10  Johnston,J lined a double down the left field line (BX)
 0-1  1 -2- 22  Stengel struck out (BCBSF2S)
 0-1  2 -2- 11  Youngs lined a double to right center, Johnston,J scored 
                  (BCX)
 0-2  2 -2- 20  Boeckel grounded out to short (BBX)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Pines batting
 0-2  0 --- 22  Gainer struck out (CBFBFS)
 0-2  1 --- 00  Stock grounded out to second (X)
 0-2  2 --- 12  Picinich grounded out to third (CCBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Giants batting
 0-2  0 --- 12  Snyder,F grounded out to short (FFBFX)
 0-2  1 --- 30  Williams,C walked (BBBB)
 0-2  1 1-- 00  Williams,C stole second (>C)
 0-2  1 -2- 22  Terry flied out to center (>C.BFBFFX)
 0-2  2 -2- 10  Holke grounded out to short (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Pines batting
 0-2  0 --- 22  Fletcher struck out (CBFBS)
 0-2  1 --- 32  Strunk grounded out to the mound (BBCFBFX)
 0-2  2 --- 01  Smith,S grounded out to second (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Giants batting
 0-2  0 --- 02  Schupp struck out (FFS)
 0-2  1 --- 01  Johnston,J lined a single to right center (FX)
 0-2  1 1-- 10  Johnston,J to second, Stengel to first on an error by the 
                  second baseman Herzog (BX)
 0-2  1 12- 02  Youngs grounded a single up the middle, Johnston,J 
                  scored, Stengel to second (CCX)
 0-3  1 12- 31  Boeckel walked, Stengel to third, Youngs to second (CBBBB)
 0-3  1 123 21  Snyder,F grounded into a double play, Stock to Picinich 
                  to Gainer (FBBX)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Pines batting
 0-3  0 --- 00  Smith,R grounded a double down the third base line (X)
 0-3  0 -2- 32  Hooper grounded out to second, Smith,R to third (BSBSBX)
 0-3  1 --3 22  Herzog grounded out to second, Smith,R scored (CFBBX)
 1-3  2 --- 32  Gainer walked (BBBCFB)
 1-3  2 1-- 00  Stock grounded out to second (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Giants batting
 1-3  0 --- 22  Williams,C struck out (BBFSC)
 1-3  1 --- 01  Terry popped out to first (CX)
 1-3  2 --- 00  Holke grounded out to second (X)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Pines batting
 1-3  0 --- 31  Picinich grounded a single to left (CBBBX)
 1-3  0 1-- 00  Fletcher grounded a single between first and second, 
                  Picinich to second (>X)
                Barry pinch hitting for Strunk
 1-3  0 12- 21  Barry grounded out to short, Picinich to third, Fletcher 
                  to second (CBBX)
 1-3  1 -23 32  Smith,S walked (CBBFFBB)
 1-3  1 123 32  Smith,R popped out to center (BCFBBX)
                Janvrin pinch hitting for Hooper
 1-3  2 123 31  Janvrin lined a single to left center, Picinich scored, 
                  Fletcher scored, Smith,S to third (BBBCX)
 3-3  2 1-3 21  Herzog grounded a single up the middle, Smith,S scored, 
                  Janvrin to third (FB1BX)
 4-3  2 1-3 00  Gainer lined a single to shallow left, Janvrin scored, 
                  Herzog to second (X)
                Smith,Ji now playing shortstop
                Horstmann now pitching
 5-3  2 12- 01  Stock grounded out to second (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Giants batting
                Williams,K now playing center field
                Sloan now playing right field
                Ayers now pitching
 5-3  0 --- 11  Smith,Ji grounded out to third (BSX)
 5-3  1 --- 12  Johnston,J lined a single to shallow left (CBFX)
 5-3  1 1-- 32  Stengel walked, Johnston,J to second (B1BFBCFB)
 5-3  1 12- 20  Johnston,J to third, Stengel to second, Youngs to first 
                  on an error by the pitcher Ayers (BBX)
 5-3  1 123 11  Boeckel lined out to left, Johnston,J scored (BCX)
                Smith,Ea pinch hitting for Snyder,F
 5-4  2 12- 12  Smith,Ea grounded to short, forcing Youngs at second 
                  (BFCFX)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Pines batting
                Tragesser now playing catcher
 5-4  0 --- 01  Picinich grounded out to short (CX)
 5-4  1 --- 30  Fletcher walked (BBBB)
 5-4  1 1-- 02  Tragesser allowed a passed ball, Fletcher to second (S1CB)
 5-4  1 -2- 32  Williams,K struck out (S1CB.BBS)
 5-4  2 -2- 31  Sloan walked (FBBBB)
 5-4  2 12- 00  Smith,R flied out to left (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Giants batting
 5-4  0 --- 22  Williams,C lined a double down the right field line 
                  (SCBBFX)
                Jamieson pinch hitting for Horstmann
 5-4  0 -2- 12  Jamieson flied out to left (SBSX)
 5-4  1 -2- 30  Holke was walked intentionally (IIII)
                Watson,Mi now pitching
 5-4  1 12- 00  Smith,Ji flied out to left, Williams,C to third (X)
 5-4  2 1-3 32  Johnston,J popped out to first (BB1FBF>X)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Pines batting
                Snyder,B now pitching
 5-4  0 --- 00  Watson,Mi flied out to right (X)
 5-4  1 --- 22  Herzog grounded out to second (FBFFFBX)
 5-4  2 --- 32  Gainer struck out (BCBFBFC)
 
**************  Bottom of the 9th inning, Giants batting
 5-4  0 --- 10  Stengel popped out to second (BX)
 5-4  1 --- 01  Youngs grounded out to the mound (CX)
 5-4  2 --- 31  Boeckel walked (BBBCB)
 5-4  2 1-- 00  Boeckel stole second (>B)
 5-4  2 -2- 22  Tragesser lined a single to shallow center, Boeckel 
                  scored (>B.CBSX)
                Kerr pinch running for Tragesser
 5-5  2 1-- 30  Williams,C walked, Kerr to second (1BBBB)
 5-5  2 12- 00  Snyder,B flied out to center (X)
 
**************  Top of the 10th inning, Pines batting
                Smith,ES now playing catcher
 5-5  0 --- 11  Stock grounded out to first (CBX)
 5-5  1 --- 32  Picinich grounded out to third (CCBBBX)
 5-5  2 --- 20  Fletcher grounded a single up the middle (BBX)
 5-5  2 1-- 20  Williams,K flied out to center (BBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 10th inning, Giants batting
 5-5  0 --- 02  Holke popped out to left (CFX)
 5-5  1 --- 12  Smith,Ji struck out (CBFS)
 5-5  2 --- 01  Johnston,J flied out to center (FX)
 
**************  Top of the 11th inning, Pines batting
 5-5  0 --- 22  Sloan struck out (BFSBS)
 5-5  1 --- 12  Smith,R grounded out to first (CBFX)
 5-5  2 --- 11  Watson,Mi grounded out to short (BCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 11th inning, Giants batting
 5-5  0 --- 02  Stengel grounded out to second (CSX)
 5-5  1 --- 22  Youngs grounded a single between third and short (BFBFX)
 5-5  1 1-- 00  Boeckel grounded into a double play, Herzog to Fletcher 
                  to Gainer (1X)
 
**************  Top of the 12th inning, Pines batting
 5-5  0 --- 21  Herzog grounded out to the catcher (BBSX)
 5-5  1 --- 10  Gainer flied out to right (BX)
 5-5  2 --- 00  Stock grounded out to short (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 12th inning, Giants batting
 5-5  0 --- 21  Smith,ES doubled deep to right (BCBX)
                Thompson now pitching
 5-5  0 -2- 30  Williams,C was walked intentionally (IIII)
                Ragan pinch hitting for Snyder,B
 5-5  0 12- 02  Ragan reached on an infield single to third, Smith,ES to 
                  third, Williams,C to second (SCX)
 5-5  0 123 10  Holke lined a single to left, Smith,ES scored, Williams,C 
                  to third, Ragan to second (BX)