4/12/1919, Ga19-Geo19, Comiskey Park 
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Pines             2  0  1  1  0  1  0  0  0     5 10  1     6  1
1919 Giants            0  0  0  4  0  2  0  0  x     6  8  2     6  0
 
Pines                AB  R  H BI   AVG    Giants               AB  R  H BI   AVG
Smith,R           cf  5  0  1  1  .160    Holke             1b  4  0  0  1  .100
Hooper            rf  4  0  0  1  .364    Williams,C        cf  4  0  0  0  .160
Herzog            2b  4  2  1  0  .188    Youngs            rf  2  1  0  0  .476
Stock             3b  4  1  1  0  .280    Carroll           lf  3  1  2  0  .800
Fletcher          ss  4  0  3  2  .231    Boeckel           3b  4  0  0  1  .333
Thompson          lf  3  0  1  1  .143     Dubuc            p   0  0  0  0  .000
Gainer            1b  4  0  0  0  .136    Johnston,J        2b  4  1  2  1  .348
Schmidt           c   4  0  0  0  .200    Terry             ss  3  2  2  1  .273
Naylor            p   2  1  2  0  .500    Tragesser         c   4  1  2  1  .300
 Watson,Mi        p   1  1  1  0  .500    Mays              p   3  0  0  1  .111
 Wilkinson        p   0  0  0  0  .000     Caton            3b  1  0  0  0  .000
 Janvrin          ph  1  0  0  0  .000                         32  6  8  6
                     36  5 10  5
 
Pines                            INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Naylor                           3.1  5  4  4  3  0  66  35  4.76
Watson,Mi                        2.0  2  1  1  1  0  28  17  3.48
Wilkinson        BS 1, L 0-2     2.2  1  1  0  0  0  38  25  2.35
                                 8.0  8  6  5  4  0 132  77 
 
Giants                           INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Mays             W 2-0           7.0 10  5  3  0  1 117  77  1.89
Dubuc            S 1             2.0  0  0  0  0  1  16  11  2.25
                                 9.0 10  5  3  0  2 133  88 
 
Ga : Janvrin batted for Wilkinson in the 9th
Geo: Caton inserted at 3b in the 8th
 
E-Gainer, Carroll, Johnston,J. 2B-Watson,Mi(1), Tragesser 2(2). 
3B-Johnston,J(1). RBI-Smith,R(2), Hooper(3), Fletcher 2(3), Thompson(2), 
Holke(2), Boeckel(4), Johnston,J(3), Terry(2), Tragesser(2), Mays(2). 
SB-Carroll(2), Terry(1). CS-Johnston,J. K-Gainer, Schmidt. BB-Youngs 2, 
Carroll, Terry. SH-Thompson. SF-Hooper. WP-Mays. 
GWRBI: Holke
Temperature: 71, Sky: clear, Wind: left to right at 9 MPH.
4/12/1919, Ga19-Geo19, Comiskey Park 
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Pines             2  0  1  1  0  1  0  0  0     5 10  1     6  1
1919 Giants            0  0  0  4  0  2  0  0  x     6  8  2     6  0
 
 
Pines                -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Smith,R           cf 1>43           7            e7.1-3;B-2   note 1       3/fl      
Hooper            rf   3/g          8            note 2     7>63           3/g       
Herzog            2b   S          3>e4.B-2       7            43                     
Stock             3b   S.1-3        7          5>9            9                      
Fletcher          ss   S.3-H;1-2    S.2-H        8          8>S                      
Thompson          lf   S.2-H;1-3    6            9            Dubuc                  
                                                              3/SH.1-2               
Gainer            1b   54/f         wp.1-2     6>7            k                      
                                    43                                               
Schmidt           c  2>43         4>k            43           63                     
Naylor            p    S            S                                                
 Watson,Mi        p                              D                                   
 Wilkinson        p                                                                  
 Janvrin          ph                                        9>63                     
 
 1: S.2-H;Bx2(854)  2: 7/SF.3-H;2-3 
 
 
Giants               -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Holke             1b 1>7            63           2/fl         note 1                 
Williams,C        cf   9            63         5>9            6                      
Youngs            rf   W          4>W            8            3/g                    
Carroll           lf   W.1-2        S.1-3        S          7>53                     
Boeckel           3b   2/fl         53.3-H;1-2   SB2          31                     
                                                 43                                  
 Dubuc            p                                                                  
Johnston,J        2b 2>63           T.2-H      6>S            43                     
Terry             ss   S            S.3-H        CS2(24)    8>8                      
                                                 W                                   
Tragesser         c    643/gdp      SB2          Wilkinson    53                     
                                    D.2-H        D.1-3                               
Mays              p  3>7            Watson,Mi    note 2                              
                                    13.2-3                                           
 Caton            3b                                          43                     
 
 1: FC.3-H;1-2;B-1  2: e3.3-H;2-3;B-1 
 
 
Pines            IN OUT ER                  Giants           IN OUT ER                  
Naylor           A1  B8  4                  Mays             A1  D5  3 W 2-0            
Watson,Mi        B9  C7  1                  Dubuc            D6  E2  0 S 1              
Wilkinson        C8  D9  0 BS 1, L 0-2                                                  
4/12/1919, Ga19-Geo19, Comiskey Park 
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1919 Pines             2  0  1  1  0  1  0  0  0     5 10  1     6  1
1919 Giants            0  0  0  4  0  2  0  0  x     6  8  2     6  0
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Pines batting
 0-0  0 --- 12  Smith,R grounded out to second (CCBX)
 0-0  1 --- 00  Hooper grounded out to first (X)
 0-0  2 --- 12  Herzog lined a single to shallow center (CSBX)
 0-0  2 1-- 12  Stock lined a single down the right field line, Herzog to 
                  third (B1S11C11FX)
 0-0  2 1-3 11  Fletcher lined a single to right, Herzog scored, Stock to 
                  second (BCX)
 1-0  2 12- 11  Thompson lined a single to right center, Stock scored, 
                  Fletcher to third (CBX)
 2-0  2 1-3 12  Gainer grounded to third, forcing Thompson at second 
                  (C1BFFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Giants batting
 2-0  0 --- 21  Holke flied out to left (BCBX)
 2-0  1 --- 32  Williams,C flied out to right (BBCBCFFFFX)
 2-0  2 --- 31  Youngs walked (FBBBB)
 2-0  2 1-- 31  Carroll walked, Youngs to second (1BFBBB)
 2-0  2 12- 11  Boeckel popped out to the catcher (CBX)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Pines batting
 2-0  0 --- 22  Schmidt grounded out to second (CBFBFX)
 2-0  1 --- 00  Naylor lined a single up the middle (X)
 2-0  1 1-- 21  Smith,R lined out to left (FBBX)
 2-0  2 1-- 02  Hooper flied out to center (CFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Giants batting
 2-0  0 --- 10  Johnston,J grounded out to short (BX)
 2-0  1 --- 00  Terry lined a single down the right field line (X)
 2-0  1 1-- 10  Tragesser grounded into a double play, Fletcher to Herzog 
                  to Gainer (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Pines batting
 2-0  0 --- 00  Herzog to second on an error by the second baseman 
                  Johnston,J (X)
 2-0  0 -2- 21  Stock popped out to left (BBSbX)
 2-0  1 -2- 12  Fletcher lined a single to left center, Herzog scored 
                  (CFBX)
 3-0  1 1-- 21  Thompson popped out to short (FBBX)
 3-0  2 1-- 01  Mays threw a wild pitch, Fletcher to second (SB)
 3-0  2 -2- 12  Gainer grounded out to second (SB.FX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Giants batting
 3-0  0 --- 21  Mays flied out to left (BCBX)
 3-0  1 --- 11  Holke grounded out to short (FBX)
 3-0  2 --- 20  Williams,C grounded out to short (BBX)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Pines batting
 3-0  0 --- 22  Schmidt struck out (BSCBFS)
 3-0  1 --- 22  Naylor grounded a single between first and second (FBFBX)
 3-0  1 1-- 31  Naylor to third, Smith,R to second on an error by the 
                  left fielder Carroll (BBCBX)
 3-0  1 -23 31  Hooper hit a sacrifice fly to left, Naylor scored, 
                  Smith,R to third (BBCBX)
 4-0  2 --3 22  Herzog flied out to left (BBCCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Giants batting
 4-0  0 --- 32  Youngs walked (BFBFFBFB)
 4-0  0 1-- 10  Carroll lined a single to right, Youngs to third (BX)
 4-0  0 1-3 00  Boeckel grounded out to third, Youngs scored, Carroll to 
                  second (>X)
 4-1  1 -2- 32  Johnston,J tripled deep to right center, Carroll scored 
                  (BCBBCFFX)
 4-2  1 --3 10  Terry lined a single to left, Johnston,J scored (BX)
 4-3  1 1-- 00  Terry stole second (>B)
 4-3  1 -2- 11  Tragesser lined a double down the third base line, Terry 
                  scored (>B.SX)
                Watson,Mi now pitching
 4-4  1 -2- 12  Mays grounded out to the mound, Tragesser to third (BFCX)
 4-4  2 --3 10  Holke popped out to the catcher (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Pines batting
 4-4  0 --- 11  Stock flied out to right (BSX)
 4-4  1 --- 10  Fletcher popped out to center (BX)
 4-4  2 --- 02  Thompson flied out to right (FCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Giants batting
 4-4  0 --- 00  Williams,C popped out to right (X)
 4-4  1 --- 00  Youngs flied out to center (X)
 4-4  2 --- 22  Carroll grounded a single between first and second 
                  (CBBFFX)
 4-4  2 1-- 00  Carroll stole second (111)
 4-4  2 -2- 10  Boeckel grounded out to second (111.BX)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Pines batting
 4-4  0 --- 11  Gainer lined out to left (CBX)
 4-4  1 --- 32  Schmidt grounded out to second (BFBFFFBX)
 4-4  2 --- 11  Watson,Mi grounded a double down the third base line (CBX)
 4-4  2 -2- 20  Smith,R lined a single to shallow center, Watson,Mi 
                  scored, Smith,R out at second (BBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Giants batting
 5-4  0 --- 20  Johnston,J grounded a single up the middle (BBX)
 5-4  0 1-- 01  Johnston,J was caught stealing second (1Sb>B)
 5-4  1 --- 32  Terry walked (1Sb>B.BBCFFFB)
                Wilkinson now pitching
 5-4  1 1-- 10  Tragesser doubled deep to left, Terry to third (BX)
 5-4  1 -23 02  Terry scored, Tragesser to third, Mays to first on an 
                  error by the first baseman Gainer (FFFX)
 5-5  1 1-3 01  Holke reached on a fielder's choice to short, Tragesser 
                  scored, Mays to second, Holke to first (FX)
 5-6  1 12- 32  Williams,C popped out to short (BBSCFBX)
 5-6  2 12- 11  Youngs grounded out to first (BFX)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Pines batting
 5-6  0 --- 00  Hooper grounded out to short (X)
 5-6  1 --- 12  Herzog grounded out to second (BSCX)
 5-6  2 --- 10  Stock flied out to right (BX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Giants batting
 5-6  0 --- 12  Carroll grounded out to third (FFBX)
 5-6  1 --- 21  Boeckel grounded out to first (BBCX)
 5-6  2 --- 10  Johnston,J grounded out to second (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Pines batting
 5-6  0 --- 11  Fletcher lined a single to right (BFX)
                Caton now playing third base
                Dubuc now pitching
 5-6  0 1-- 01  Thompson sacrifice bunted to first, Fletcher to second 
                  (FXb)
 5-6  1 -2- 02  Gainer struck out (CFS)
 5-6  2 -2- 01  Schmidt grounded out to short (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Giants batting
 5-6  0 --- 11  Terry flied out to center (CBX)
 5-6  1 --- 11  Tragesser grounded out to third (BCX)
 5-6  2 --- 21  Caton grounded out to second (BBCX)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Pines batting
                Janvrin pinch hitting for Wilkinson
 5-6  0 --- 20  Janvrin grounded out to short (BBX)
 5-6  1 --- 10  Smith,R popped out to first (BX)
 5-6  2 --- 21  Hooper grounded out to first (BBFX)